“Some books should be tasted, some devoured, but only a few should be chewed and digested thoroughly.” ― Sir Francis Bacon

[
[
[

]
]
]

I guess I didn’t read the jacket blurb(s) closely enough, because I went into this one expecting more of a Bourne Identity vibe. But although Myfanwy Thomas *is* an operative in a secret society, and an internal betrayal *does* leave her scrambling for her life with a target painted on her back, the mood of The Rook is far from gritty. It’s unabashedly campy and occasionally teeters on the edge of the absurd, much more The Laundry Files than The X-Files.

It was a fun read, but for me the story is trapped in a bit of an uncanny valley. A lot of it feels intentionally tongue-in-cheek, but it’s not absurd or cleverly campy enough to be memorable *because of* its humor (unlike, say, Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy). And from the espionage side, sure, there’s a plot there, but given the lighthearted tone there’s no real sense of suspense or risk, so it doesn’t knock that one out of the park either.

Then there’s the decision to handle a lot of the exposition by dropping in a letter every few chapters written to Myfanwy by, let’s say, “a mentor.” The secret society’s history; background info on the politics, powers, and personalities of its ruling Council; and even a few diary-entry-style flashbacks are all delivered this way. There’s nothing wrong with that approach per se, but when almost all of the worldbuilding happens in this kind of primer format, it feels less like a living world and more like a TTRPG source book.

On the plus side, Myfanwy is a sympathetic character, the superhuman abilities of both the operatives and their adversaries are creative and varied, and everything moves along at a pretty comfortable clip. There’s enough time devoted to Myfanwy’s internal monologue to flesh her out as a character, but it’s never at the expense of hitting the next story beat.

Overall I give The Rook a serviceable 3 stars. If you like the premise – “Kingsman: The Secret Service, but keeping a lid on the hidden world of cultists and eldritch horrors” – then I think you’ll be entertained. If you’re looking for something that will stick in your head a while after you’ve put it back on the shelf, this is probably not the one for you.

Leave a Reply